DEPARTMENTS
RISK MANAGEMENT
MAEVE CROWNE, BASc, is junior EHS specialist at WSP Golder, Mine Environment in Sudbury, Ontario, providing EHS-, ESG-, and community-related services to clients in the mining sector.
DOUGLAS MCNEIL, BA, is senior principal for EHS at WSP in Toronto, Ontario, providing EHS- and ESG-related services to clients in various sectors.
NANCY E. WILK, MHSc, CIH, is senior principal for EHS at WSP Golder, Mine Environment in Cambridge, Ontario, providing leadership and oversight in EHS- and ESG-related services. She is the current vice chair of the AIHA Total Exposure Health/Total Worker Health Advisory Group.
Send feedback to The Synergist.
Potential Collaborations for Mitigating Risks in TWH and ESG
BY MAEVE CROWNE, DOUGLAS MCNEIL, AND NANCY E. WILK
Over the last two years, the AIHA Total Exposure Health/Total Worker Health Advisory Group has been examining the TWH approach established by NIOSH, the issues relevant to advancing worker well-being, and opportunities for exposure scientists to collaborate with other stakeholders. It has become apparent that several TWH issues align with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and environmental, social, and governance (ESG) efforts at local, national, and global levels. This alignment suggests broad areas where fruitful collaboration is possible.
NIOSH has been providing solutions to support worker health initiatives since 2003, beginning with a program called Worklife, which was later renamed TWH. TWH introduced the integration of occupational safety and health with disease prevention and healthy workplace behaviors. NIOSH defines TWH as “policies, programs, and practices that integrate protection from work-related safety and health hazards with promotion of injury and illness prevention efforts to advance worker well-being.” A NIOSH publication on TWH (PDF) identifies numerous issues relevant to advancing worker well-being, including health, community, and environmental risks, that expand beyond the traditional approach to occupational health and safety. AIHA further elaborates on these issues in a guidance document released earlier this year (PDF). Research shows that workers’ health and well-being is directly impacted by the environment in which they live, the society from whom they may seek support, and various multi-faceted economic factors.
TWH AND ESG
TWH and ESG both focus on the mitigation of risk. For ESG, the risks and opportunities include climate change, ethical labor practices, data privacy, and diversity, equity, and inclusion, to name a few. For TWH, the risks include hazards and exposures that can result in life-altering or life-threatening disease or injury, while the opportunities encompass inclusive work and community environments, increased worker productivity and retention, improved worker well-being, and more sustainable products and supply chains.
The global ESG movement, which includes capital markets, is challenging organizations to deliver on their environmental and social obligations and economic commitments while mitigating risks of injury and illness for workers. The TWH framework, with its data-driven approach to worker and community health, offers solutions and opportunities related to ESG international frameworks and standards requirements. Specifically, the collaboration of exposure scientists and TWH stakeholders with those focused on ESG could position organizations to better achieve ESG criteria, advance worker well-being, and mitigate risks.
To meet their fiduciary obligations, asset owners and managers are increasingly interested in understanding how ESG risk and opportunity can be integrated into business activities and products. TWH offers opportunities for alignment with the desires of investors who have needs and preferences related to ESG. According to the CFA Institute, a global standard-setting association for investment professionals, these desires include incorporating ethical principles and values, mitigating negative impacts on the environment and people, and contributing to achieving specific, positive, and measurable environmental or social outcomes. The intersection of these shared desires and common issues offers opportunity for asset managers, investors, and exposure scientists to work together and effectively mitigate shared risks.
Addressing risks in a holistic manner, rather than individually, will achieve more effective mitigation and innovations in risk prevention.
TWH AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
The UN SDGs were launched in 2015 to meet urgent, global challenges and provide a blueprint for addressing basic needs, empowerment, climate change, natural capital, and governance. The 17 SDGs have been adopted by all 193 UN member states. Organizations around the world that identify as socially responsible corporate citizens began committing to the SDGs in early 2016 and created strategic plans for achieving them. Organizations now routinely communicate their commitment (and report on their performance) related to climate policies, energy use, waste, pollution, natural resource conservation, greenhouse gas emissions, environmental compliance, community volunteer opportunities, health and safety performance, ethics, and diversity, equity, and inclusion.
Several SDGs intersect with TWH, including good health and well-being (SDG3), gender equality (SDG5), decent work and economic growth (SDG8), sustainable cities and communities (SDG11), and partnerships for the goals (SDG17). To elaborate further, SDG3—good health and well-being—intersects with TWH through its focus on disease-related mortality reduction, mental health promotion, prevention and treatment of substance abuse, tobacco control, access to affordable vaccines and medicines, and reduction of illnesses and deaths from hazardous chemicals and pollution. TWH issues intersecting with this SDG include biological, chemical, and physical agents; ergonomic factors; psychosocial factors; accessible and affordable health-enhancing options; healthy workspace design and environment; safe, secure, and clean facilities; access to green spaces and pathways; safe, healthy, and affordable housing options; chronic disease prevention and management programs; and employee assistance and substance use disorder programs.
In 2021, the UN adopted resolution 48/13 pertaining to the human right to a clean, healthy, and sustainable environment. Human health and quality of life are severely compromised in locations known as “sacrifice zones” where residents experience devastating physical and mental health effects from living in heavily contaminated areas and places that have become (or are becoming) uninhabitable because of extreme weather events or slow-onset disasters resulting from the climate crisis (such as drought, sea-level rise, and epidemic disease). TWH and the SDGs both address growing barriers that individuals face in achieving healthy living and well-being such as those resulting from the climate crisis.
SDG17, partnerships for the goals, is notable for its many opportunities for collaboration. The SDGs and the aims of TWH can be best achieved through collaboration of stakeholders and the management of human and financial resources. SDG17 intersects with TWH in the SDG target areas of knowledge sharing and cooperation for access to science, technology, and innovation; encouraging effective partnerships; and enhancing availability of reliable data. The AIHA guidance on TWH identifies the underlying principles of partnerships and the integration of knowledge and disciplines as the keys to delivering on TWH and TEH. TWH and TEH are data driven; access to and sharing of reliable data are critical. Most issues identified by NIOSH in advancing worker well-being will be effectively addressed through strong partnerships, knowledge sharing, access to science, technology, and innovation, and enhanced availability of reliable scientific data.
STIMULATING INNOVATION
Advancing worker well-being also requires advancing community safety and well-being. These needs present issues and risks that traditional approaches to worker health and safety have not previously considered. Addressing risks in a holistic manner, rather than individually, will achieve more effective mitigation and innovations in risk prevention. Risk management conversations pose opportunities for individuals who are typically left out of discussions about worker health and well-being to provide input. ESG has room for input from and interaction with all stakeholders, including workers, planners, investors, exposure scientists, and others.
Designed to achieve a better and more sustainable future for everyone, the SDGs are based on the simple premises of “do no harm” and “do good.” Similarly, TWH aims to eliminate harm and advance worker well-being. There is urgent global need to prevent occupational disease and fatality and to achieve the SDGs and the goals of ESG. Integration and teamwork can accomplish more than individual efforts. Diverse needs and complex issues require diverse knowledge, commitment, innovation, and resources.
In his book The Medici Effect, Frans Johansson argues that the collaboration of diverse industries, cultures, and disciplines results in an explosion of innovation. Given the many intersections discussed in this article, now seems an appropriate time to foster collaboration between those focused on TWH and ESG to stimulate innovations in mitigating shared risks, achieving ESG criteria, and advancing worker well-being and community health.
RESOURCES
AIHA: “AIHA Total Exposure Health Aspects of Total Worker Health: Advancing Worker Well-Being” (PDF, May 2022).
Harvard Business School Press: The Medici Effect: Breakthrough Insights at the Intersection of Ideas, Concepts, and Cultures (2004).
NIOSH: “Fundamentals of Total Worker Health Approaches: Essential Elements for Advancing Worker Safety, Health, and Well-Being” (PDF, December 2016).